why is this so hard for transphobes to understand?
Why is this so hard for transphobes to understand?
Cuz trans women look and act male.
it’s not based in reality, like sorry but there is a huge diff between a transsexual and a self-identified trans woman. someone with a big beard and a deep voice just isn’t ever gonna be considered a woman
this is what set us back so far. pulling away from medicalism into "i'm trans and a woman because uuuhh... because i le am :)" has done damage which i fear might not be reversible
Telling a doctor you feel female means nothing.
Can I be a male woman?
ok?
Why cannot those girls from countries where they are unable leave their home, go to school or exist without a male relative next to them just change their gender to male? Are they stupid?
Thats all transmedicalism is.
That’s literally not how it works. Some people are trans because they are born in the wrong body. They have severe dysphoria and need MEDICAL help, but what you are saying hurts trans people too and is bullshit.
Because of you I’m bringing back the term transsexual.
real. i've been calling myself a transsexual for a while now.
because art imitates life and the smugness of the one holding the sign is immense.
what ever happened to respect one another regardless of their difference. preach tolerance.
yes hun
castration is destruction, not medical help
Sounds cool, means nothing
Luckshit features on his face. No long midface or long horse philtrum but absolutely everything else ruins it
To be a woman you have to live as one full time and be perceived by others as one. That way you enter and experience womanhood
Identifying as a woman in your subreddit isnt real
Unga bunga is woman.
Unga bunga is happy.
turks be like
and this is my mom
They are too racist and misogynistic to accept that women can come in all shapes and colors
i think this idea of 'you are a woman if you identify as one' has set back trans rights to a point worse than the 1970s. from reading contemporary stuff i think most cis people then either didn't know anything about trans people or had some idea of them as 'people who got a sex change' or 'were born the wrong way'. now we have large numbers that are learning about trans people as people whose 'identity doesn't match their body' and end up thinking about our gender as an expression of our personality, like how flamboyant gay men might dress in a feminine way but more extreme. honestly if i was a cis person who knew nothing about dysphoria learning about trans people in this way i would probably think negatively about them too. i understand that the goal was to be more inclusive but imo it has backfired spectacularly, it might take decades for public perception to recover.
Because it's false. A woman is anyone I identify as a woman.
A woman is an adult human whose non blood cells mostly lack y chromosomes.
Bro dont post my mom here
Not a single attractive young white woman in that picture. Most of them are niggers. Anyway, fuck trannies. I'ma misgender those bastards.
Not an argument. is right, all transmedicalism is is submission to a doctor that in all likelihood hates you and wants you to fail.
transmedicalism in this context refers to "being trans" actually being gender dysphoria, treated with hrt
And why does any of that require seeing a doctor that hates you?
Because self-identity means nothing. It's fucking retarded and tumblr. Grow out of it already.
screenshot and underline where i said that. i've never seen a doctor about being trans. I DIY and know i have gender dysphoria because it's my lived experience. it's completely different to a non-dysphoric cis person saying "i'm a woman" just because they want to be quirky or fit in with trannies
it's completely different to a non-dysphoric cis person saying "i'm a woman" just because they want to be quirky or fit in with trannies
This is a marginal phenomenon and not a good argument to fight against self-ID and OTC HRT.
fight against OTC HRT.
you're projecting a lot of things i didn't say onto me
Transmedicalism implies you should need a diagnosis in order to access treatment.
I'm straight so a woman is anyone who gets my dick hard faggot.
Nta but "transmedicalism" is pretty diluted nowadays. Pretty sure it's now just "hrt = trans, no hrt = no trans".
That’s like 95% of ftms (hefabs) tbhon
wrong, a woman is whoever looks/sounds like one
ergo i'm not a woman
even if being transgender is caused by or is essentially a medical condition, it does not follow that you need a diagnosis of that condition to be trans or receive treatment. for example whether or not someone is a diabetic is a medical fact independent of any diagnosis, and they may well treat themselves with medicines with good results for various reasons such as lack of money or access to informed doctors. that being trans is contingent on having actually received a diagnosis is ridiculous and not something anybody seriously believes; a diagnosis is just a medical opinion and most psychiatrists will be of the opinion that you have GD simply as a result of telling them you are trans.
Then you aren't a transmedicalist. Transmedicalism always implies gatekeeping by medical professionals.
In that case transmeds would accept hrt manmoders as trans but in many cases they do not. I think transmed should be called trans positivism.
i am neither the original anon nor consider myself a transmedicalist but as i said i think you hold a strawman view of transmedicalism not seriously held by actual people.
i think you hold a strawman view of transmedicalism not seriously held by actual people.
proven by the fact that they keep implying shit the post they're replying to didn't actually say
I think the real problem is treating gender dysphoria as a static condition when nothing in the diagnostic criteria implies it’s fixed. The criteria has a 6 month duration for a reason. Dudes go down a 2 week goonhole on female supremacy imagefap captions after losing their job and after browsing Reddit think theyve been afflicted with the transgender status condition since birth. They hop on HRT and confirm this diagnosis because they feel good being hormonally balanced for once as well as the SSRI effects of estrogen.
implying a goonhole trip can't last longer than 6 months
the problem with relying on DSM criteria is that psychiatrists are normies
yeah that’s true as well. Self aware coomers would revolutionize the psychology profession and it’s understanding of human sexuality if we could stop cooming long enough to go get our degrees .